x264 vs NVENC on a mid-range PC
The common advice is that x264 looks better at the same bitrate. On my machine that was true only when the game itself was light. In anything with particles, x264 at "veryfast" started dropping frames, and dropped frames look far worse than slightly softer detail.
What I ended up with
Encoder: hardware (NVENC) Rate control: CBR, 6000 kbps Keyframe: 2 s Preset: quality, two-pass off Profile: high Look-ahead: off (cost more than it gave) Psycho visual: on
900p60 looked noticeably smoother for fast games than 1080p30, and viewers on phones could not tell the resolution difference anyway.